Trust – Creditor Rights & Claims

How Does the Successor Trustee Handle the Bills and Debts of the Deceased Trustor?

LIVING TRUST ADMINISTRATION

Successor Trustee paying trustor debtsIf there is a living trust and all of the deceased person’s assets have been placed into the living trust prior to death, there is no need for a probate court administration. Creditor Rights? For probates, there are specific court-supervised formal steps required to notify creditors and for approval and rejection of creditor’s claims. The situation involving a trust is much less formal and the laws differ somewhat. The person who administers a living trust following the death of the trustors (the persons who created the trust) is known as the successor trustee.

The successor trustee’s job is to follow the directions in the trust for the distribution of the trust estate to the beneficiaries. The successor trustee’s job may also be to pay the debts and bills of the trustors before distributing the estate to the beneficiaries, depending upon how the trust is worded.

TRUST & BENEFICIARIES GENERALLY LIABLE FOR THE DEBTS

By law, a living/revocable trust is liable for the debts of the trustors. The death of the trustors causes the living trust to become permanent and irrevocable. However, the debts still remain and the creditors to whom the debts are owed have rights against the trust to collect the money owed if the trust was revocable at the date of death of the trustors. If the successor trustee does not pay the debts but instead distributes the trust assets to the beneficiaries, then the creditors can sue the beneficiaries. In other words, the trust assets passed to the beneficiaries are still liable for the debts of the trustors. If the beneficiaries are sued by the creditors then they can cross-complain back against the successor trustee for failing to pay the debts. For this reason, a successor trustee may want to use the optional trust creditors claim procedure discussed below.

LEGAL LIMITS FOR CREDITORS TO FILE LAWSUITS TO COLLECT

California law has special statutes of limitation dealing with claims against deceased persons. These statutes bar any lawsuit on a liability of a deceased person unless the lawsuit is filed before the first anniversary of the decedent’s death. This one-year legal limit applies to debts which were owned by the trustors of a living trust. Creditors need to act quickly to protect their claims on the one hand and also trustees must be sure to not pay claims that are barred by the one year limit. Because of the one year limit, the trustee cannot safely payout the trust assets to the beneficiaries before the one year expires. As explained below, there is an optional procedure to cut down the claim period from one year to approximately 4 months. TAX EXCEPTION: The one year limit or the optional 4 month claim deadline does not apply to money owing to the Internal Revenue Service for taxes.

CREDITORS & DEBTS

Persons or companies who are owed money by the deceased person are known as creditors. Creditors include those with contract claims, tort claims (as an accident claim for example), or otherwise. The California and local government agencies including the franchise tax board are generally subject to the same creditor claims and notification rules. However, taxes owing to the federal government are covered by federal law which allows a longer period to collect.

NOTIFICATION TO CREDITORS GENERALLY

Unless the optional trust creditors claim procedure is used, the successor trustee is not legally required to notify the creditors of the death of the trustors. This is in sharp contrast to a probate proceeding where the personal representative does need to send out a notice to “all known and reason-ably ascertainable creditors” in the mail.

NOTIFICATIONS TO VARIOUS STATE AGENCIES

Even if the optional trust claims procedure is NOT used, the law does require a successor trustee to notice various state agencies. The state agencies one is normally concerned with are the state board of equalization tax claims, franchise tax board tax claims, Department of human resources development claims, Department of mental health claims, Department of Health care services claims, and Medi-Cal claims. If a particular department has its own claim form that must be used. Also, if the deceased trustor received state aid under the Medi-Cal or Medicaid pro-gram, the successor trustee must give notice to the Director or health care services no later than 90 days after the deceased trustor’s death.

FACTORS AGAINST USING THE OPTIONAL TRUST CLAIMS PROCEDURE

Use of the procedure is an invitation to creditors to make claims against trust property. Successor trustees have no legal duty to use the optional claims procedure and should use the procedure only if it furthers the successor trustee’s duty to administer the trust for the interests of the beneficiaries. If the trust has many beneficiaries or the beneficiaries live outside of California, liability of the beneficiaries as distributees may not matter because the creditors would find it difficult to collect from the beneficiaries.

FACTORS IN FAVOR OF USING THE OPTIONAL TRUST CLAIMS PROCEDURE

Where there a lot of debts and/or shortage of trust money to pay the debts then use of the procedure may slow the creditors down or get them to write-off smaller claims. If the trust has only one or two beneficiaries who live in California it would be relatively easy for a creditor to pursue property received from the trust. Trustees can deduct the cost of defending claims which is a legal and expense of administration. However, a beneficiary who was sued could not deduct the cost of his or her defense. The time for creditors to sue on claims is cut down from one year to approximately 4 months. This shortened limitation period speeds up the ability of the successor trustee to distribute the trust assets to the beneficiaries. Requiring creditors to file formal claims reduces uncertainty regarding what actual claims exist. Using this procedure prevents the beneficiaries from any potential liability from creditors of the trustors and insulates the successor trustee from claims back against the successor trustee by the beneficiaries for failing to pay valid claims. Using this procedure assures the beneficiaries that all legitimate known debts are handled and paid. If the procedure is not used, creditors could file suit for as long as four years after the due date of the last payment.

OVERVIEW OF THE OPTIONAL TRUST CLAIMS PROCEDURE.-NOTIFICATION

A proposed notice to creditors is prepared and filed with the court clerk in the county where the deceased trustors resided. There is no published form for this notice so typically an attorney is retained to make sure the notice is properly prepared in accordance with law. There is a filing fee to be paid at the time of filing which is approximately $485. The court assigns a case number and then the notice is published once a week for four weeks in a newspaper in the town where the deceased trustors resided. Publication fees depend upon the news-paper but can go as high as $700. After the publication a proof of publication is filed with the court and that firmly establishes the beginning of the claims period. Also, the successor trustee mail send notice to “known creditors” but doesn’t have to conduct any search. Contrast the requirement in probate trust claims procedures for the personal representative to notify ”all known and reasonably ascertainable creditors”.

ALLOWANCE OR REJECTION

A cre
ditor with a claim must make a written claim and file it with the court and mail a copy to the trustee. The deadline to file is the later of 4 months after the publication of the notice to creditors or 60 days after the notice to creditor is mailed to the creditor. There is no court published form for a creditor to use but the claim must meet legal requirements. No law requires the trustee to act on the claim but if the trustee does not notify the creditor of acceptance or rejection within 30 days then the creditor can assume the claim has been rejected. Creditors have 90 days from the date of rejection to file a lawsuit to collect on the claim. The trustee can simply pay allowed claims or send a notice of allowance to the creditor and file it with the court and pay the claim when the cash becomes available. For rejected claims, the trustee must send the creditor a notice of rejection to the creditor and file it with the court. If the trustee is unsure of what to do with a claim, he/she can file a court petition to get the court to decide if the claim should be allowed, compromised or settled.

CAN A CREDITOR’S CLAIM BE COMPROMISED?

Whether or not the trustee elects the optional trust claims procedure, the successor trustee can negotiate with the creditors to see if they will accept less money than what they claim. This is often done in an estate where there is not enough money to go around. Surprisingly, a lot of creditors, and credit card companies in particular, are open to having their claims discounted and compromised to eliminate the uncertainty of not getting paid at all. Also, where claims are smaller, many creditors do not want to go to the trouble and expense of filing a lawsuit to reduce the claim to judgment since that can take a year or more.

CALL  (949) 229-7034  to speak with Lawyer  David L. Crockett

CONCLUSION

The debts and taxes of the decedent can throw a monkey wrench in the timing and distribution of the estate. It is therefore paramount for the successor to try to determine right away who the creditors are, what the claims are, and send out appropriate notices.

Conveniently located in Newport Beach near the John Wayne Airport

We are located near the Orange County California John Wayne Airport. My office is catty-corner from Fletcher-Jones Motorcars; —right behind the rear entrance of Newport Lexus on Dove Street. Here is a picture of my office building and a Google Map to get your bearings.

Attorney, Certified Public Accountant & Real Estate Broker

  

  

badges